Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Item

Topic Preservation and Relevance

Sien Cui
Citations
Altmetric:
Abstract

This essay defends conceptual engineering from the "topic preservation" objection, the worry that conceptual engineering proposals change the topic and thus do not answer existing philosophical questions. I argue that proposals made by conceptual engineers are often relevant to existing philosophical questions posed using existing concepts, since the proposed concepts share the old concepts' features of interest in context. I then argue that various accounts of "topic preservation" in the literature are implausible as general constraints on conceptual proposals, and that the initial plausibility of the topic preservation objection is due to a hasty inference from topic change to irrelevance. Since conceptual proposals can be relevant, the topic preservation objection fails as a general objection to conceptual engineering.

Comments
Description
Date
2025-05-09
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Keywords
conceptual engineering, topic preservation, relevance, metaphilosophy
Citation
Sien Cui. "Topic Preservation and Relevance." 2025. Thesis, Georgia State University. https://doi.org/10.57709/mgpw-0t93
Embargo Lift Date
2025-05-09
Embedded videos